Showing posts with label Annular wing fin questions. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Annular wing fin questions. Show all posts

Tunnel fin/annular wing talk

Hey Roy, It's Rich.

I'm a fan of fin lift too. I always semifoil my twinners and like a lot of angle, with the idea to keep the tail snug into the wave at speed. I get the rail-to-rail advantage, so now I'm wondering about that bottom section of a tunnel fin. If that surface is foiled to produce lift, does that not tend to lift the tail out of the water? And what of the cost of that lift in terms of drag?

Like I said, I am just curious...

Hi Rich,

Thanks for the questions

Regarding the middle section of the tunnel, it will produce upwards lift no matter how it's foiled, We've had good results with double foiled sections and also with single foiled ( nearly flat on the inside or 'up' side) as well. Because the tunnel is an enclosed system, pressure is more evenly distributed inside the tunnel than it would be with a planar non enclosed wing. For that reason it's easiest ( in my opinion ) to understand and visualise the lift via the Newtonian method, i.e. redirection of water flow and mass, rather than Bernoulli's system of pressure differences, although both systems ultimately give the same answers.

Whether or not it lifts the tail out of the water depends upon the angle the fin is set up at.

For example If the tunnel fin is set up parallel to the bottom, then it's running at the same angle of attack as the bottom in the fin area. So, one might expect the fin not to lift the bottom upwards. In fact it does lift the bottom though, because of the difference in the lift characteristics of the planing surface of the bottom and the tunnel. The tunnel produces more lift at lower angles of attack than the planing surface in the tail and thus lifts the board in the tail area even when running parallel to the bottom.

Adding a positive angle of lift between the tunnel and the surfboard planing surface in the fin area increases the force lifting the board.

One might expect that the tunnel, acting as an underwater lifting foil, will just keep on lifting the tail upwards if it generates enough lift to do so, in other words jacking the tail out of the water. What happens in reality is that as the tail lifts slightly, the fore and aft pitch angle of the surfboard changes. . . the surfboard pitches forward. Because the tunnel is fixed to the bottom of the board this automatically lowers the angle of attack of the tunnel. Thus a state of equilibrium is reached where the tail is riding slightly higher than it would be without the tunnel, and the tunnel is taking some of the load. The system ( if adjusted correctly ) becomes self tending.

This self tending aspect doesn't completely determine the angle of attack of the surfboard because rider mass can be redistributed to alter the trim of the board. Thus the rider can trim the board nose up and the tunnel and planing surfaces working together will lift the board out of the water, in much the same way as a surfboard usually behaves when trimmed nose up, with some added lift from the tunnel. When trimmed nose up the efffect is not to lift the tail up more than at low angles of trim, what happens is that the whole board is projected forwards and upwards in the direction in which it is pointing. . .. this is because the tunnel and the surfboard tail have a fixed relationship to each other.

The self tending aspect is greater on longer and/or heavier boards, but is still there on lighter boards.

As far as lift vs drag goes, the tunnel has a better lift/drag ratio than the surfboard planing surface because it is effectively a wing of infinite span. Tunnels also have low induced drag. So, whenever the tunnel does part of the job of producing the necessary lift which is usually done by the planing surface of the board, there is a drag advantage to be had.

According to some tunnel analyses tunnels are better at low speeds because they have high surface area, ( skin friction drag due to surafce area predominates at high speed and induced drag at low speed) Such analyses make a couple of misleading assumptions, one is mileading because it doesn't apply to the surfboard application of tunnels and is based on the areonautical assumption that the wing must provide all the necessary lift ( not the case with surfboard fins ), the other is an anomaly in the way annular wing area is measured when comparing lift/drag characteristics with planar wings..

Testing identical boards with and without tunnels it's immediately apparent that the tunnel equipped boards are faster as well as haveing more drive and hold . I'm not claiming that tunnel finned boards will always be the fastest in all situations, as there are other ways of achieving low drag, but they certainly work and are a force to be reckoned with.

Questions about Tunnel fin annular wing surfboard fin

. .. . a conversation with 'SB'on the Tree to Sea surfboard design forum.Roy, Can you explain a bit about how a tunnel fin performs and why? I'm not sure what to expect from it or what one would hope to achieve by using it. Also what is gained by combining the tunnel fin with the cut away Spitfire fin?It's an interesting subject, and there's quite a lot to it. The tunnel plus one setup can best be understood by trying a tunnel plus one equipped board without the tunnel and then with the tunnel. The tunnel plus one has more drive, hold, lift and speed than the single.So, I suggest that you install your tunnel after riding the new board with the singlefin alone.As far as the theory and practice of tunnels go, I'll get into that below :)If the idea is to provide lift in the tail then I would suppose the idea would be to foil the inside (being the top) and leave the outside (being the bottom) flat. The tunnel fins do provide lift, but the notion that this ideally requires a foil curve on the 'top' of the wing but not underneath is not correct. It's best to treat the lift generating properties of the wing using the Newtonian lift concept, which is that the wing generates lift by redirecting flow ( and thus water mass ). This is conceptually more useful than the Bernoulli principle ( although ultimately both theories produce the same answers )Now, because wing sections produce lift with 'inverted' foil sections and symmetrical sections ( and even more so with enclosed systems i.e tunnels ), it isn't the case that the foil needs to be flat on the inside and foiled on the outside in order to produce lift. In fact a tunnel which is flat on the outside is not ideal as it stalls too easily under negative angles of attack ( This occurs as the tunnel receives flow from one side of the board or the other: one side is always at a negative angle of attack )So the short answer is that both kinds of tunnels ( those foiled on both sides, and those foiled on the outside only ) produce lift.. . and either will work well. In practice it is almost impossible to foil a tunnel so that it has no foil on the inside, as this would entail a sharp 90 degree edge at the leading edge. Any rounding off of this edge introduces a foil to the inside of the tunnel by moving the apex of the leading edge towards the outside of the tunnel.The foiling isn't critical at all, as long as it's fair. A double sided foil works very well, and produces a bit more vertical lift than a single sided foil .That would indicate that either a) the intent is not to create lift after all or b) lift is created by some force other than foiling.As mentioned above, the best ( in my opinion ) way to visualise the tunnel lift is via the Newtonian treatment of lift, via flow redirection and displacement of mass . If you want to see it in terms of Bernoulli's theory that works too, but one has to realise that the pressure differentials which produce lift exist even with flat non foiled wings and inverted wings due to the angle of attack of the wing. . . . thus the classic example of the flow taking a longer path over the wing due to the curve on top of the wing is misleading as once the flat topped wing has a positive angle of attack the flow on top of the wing is forced into a longer path and lower pressure situation anyway.By the way it's good to keep in mind that the tunnel will respond (by producing lift) to angles of attack from the side as well as from below. . . in other words it produces lift horizontally and vertically and every angle in between. It doesn't just make lift upwards like a 'hydrofoil', even though that is one of its main functions.Just looking at the vertical lift component, the tunnel produces lift in the same way as the botto of the surfboard. It does so more efficiently than the surfboard bottom though because it is effectively a wing of infinite span, unlike the surfboard bottom.I've been studying the photo of the squidfish above as well as photos of the Makaha on your website and I do seem to detect a foil pattern on those tunnels. It seems to be a standard foil pattern (thicker along the leading edge and tapering down to a thinner trailing edge) and appears to be equal inside and out. Yes that's right.